1. AlphaFold3 vs. Chai-1
Live Workshop Session
🎥 Live workshop recording — AlphaFold3 Structure Prediction: what's new and why it matters
Hands-On Exercise
- Setup for the activity
- In order to make a prediction with the AlphaFold server, you’ll need a Google account to sign in.
- In order to make a prediction with Chai-Lab, you’ll need to create a free account.
- Make a monomer prediction for 1QYS with both AF3 and Chai-Lab.
- AlphaFold 3:
- Paste in the sequence for 1QYS:
MGDIQVQVNIDDNGKNFDYTYTVTTESELQKVLNELMDYIKKQGAKRVRISITARTKKEAEKFAAILIKVFAELGYNDINVTFDGDTVTVEGQLEGGSLEHHHHHH - Press the “continue and preview job” button.
- Press “confirm and submit job”.
- Paste in the sequence for 1QYS:
- Chai-Lab:
- Paste in the same sequence for 1QYS.
- Click “Run Job” to submit the prediction.
- Analysis:
- How do the predicted structures compare to the native?
- How does the AF3 prediction compare to Chai-Lab?
- How confident is each model about its prediction?
- AlphaFold 3:
- Make a multimer prediction for 8AJY with both AF3 and Chai-Lab.
- AlphaFold 3:
- Paste in the sequence for 8AJY_1 (chain A):
MLTDRGMTYDLDPKDGSSAATKPVLEVTKKVFDTAADAAGQTVTVEFKVSGAEGKYATTGYHIYWDERLEVVATKTGAYAKKGAALEDSSLAKAENNGNGVFVASGADDDFGADGVMWTVELKVPADAKAGDVYPIDVAYQWDPSKGDLFTDNKDSAQGKLMQAYFFTQGIKSSSNPSTDEYLVKANATYADGYIAIKAGEPE - Click “add entity”, make sure the molecule type to “protein”, and paste in the sequence of 8AJY_2 (chain B):
MGSSHHHHHHSSGLVPRGSHMASKPQYRLGDVDFNGIIDGRDATAVLTEYARISTGKPAEFVGNTALAADVNKDNMIDAADATHILTYYAISSTRDDITSDDYFALHQPLRG - The native structure was originally solved in the presence of 3 Ca2+ ions. Click “add entity”, change the molecule type to “ion”, and select Ca2+ to add each.
- Press the “continue and preview job” button.
- Press “confirm and submit job”.
- Paste in the sequence for 8AJY_1 (chain A):
- Chai-Lab:
- Paste in the sequence for 8AJY_1 (chain A).
- Click “Add Chain” and paste in the sequence for 8AJY_2 (chain B).
- Click “Add Ligand” and select “Ca2+” from the ion options. Repeat to add all 3 Ca2+ ions.
- Click “Run Job” to submit the prediction.
- Analysis:
- How do the predicted structures compare to the native?
- How does the AF3 prediction compare to Chai-Lab?
- How confident is each model about its prediction?
- What about the placement of the ions and the coordinating side chains?
- AlphaFold 3:
- Make a protein-ligand prediction with Chai-Lab for 2JIE (beta-glucosidase with 2-fluoro-glucose).
- Chai-Lab:
- Paste in the sequence for 2JIE (beta-glucosidase B):
MHHHHHHSENTFIFPATFMWGTSTSSYQIEGGTDEGGRTPSIWDTFCQIPGKVIGGDCGDVACDHFHHFKEDVQLMKQLGFLHYRFSVAWPRIMPAAGIINEEGLLFYEHLLDEIELAGLIPMLTLYHWDLPQWIEDEGGWTQRETIQHFKTYASVIMDRFGERINWWNTINEPYCASILGYGTGEHAPGHENWREAFTAAHHILMCHGIASNLHKEKGLTGKIGITLNMEHVDAASERPEDVAAAIRRDGFINRWFAEPLFNGKYPEDMVEWYGTYLNGLDFVQPGDMELIQQPGDFLGINYYTRSIIRSTNDASLLQVEQVHMEEPVTDMGWEIHPESFYKLLTRIEKDFSKGLPILITENGAAMRDELVNGQIEDTGRHGYIEEHLKACHRFIEEGGQLKGYFVWSFLDNFEWAWGYSKRFGIVHINYETQERTPKQSALWFKQMMAKNGF - Click “Add Ligand” and select “Custom SMILES”.
- Enter the SMILES string for 2-fluoro-glucose (G2F):
OCC1OC(O)C(F)C(O)C1O - Click “Run Job” to submit the prediction.
- Paste in the sequence for 2JIE (beta-glucosidase B):
- Analysis:
- How does the predicted structure compare to the crystal structure (2JIE)?
- Is the ligand positioned correctly in the active site?
- How well does Chai-Lab predict the protein-ligand interactions?
- What is the confidence score for the ligand placement?
- Chai-Lab: